Comment by Park Kyung Won for Hello I have this setup now: Ubuntu 18.04 one controller node has keystone, DB, horizon ... neutron controller one storage node has cinder other compute nodes have neutron and nova I've installed openstack rocky from ubuntu repository All nodes(controller and compute nodes) has two interfaces, management(MGMT) and data(DATA) MGMT interface is connected to management switch and DATA interface is connected to data switch and data switch is connected to physical router(172.16.0.1/24) What I can do: - I can create provider network - I can create self-service network - I can attach my VM instance to both provider or self-service network - My VM gets IP from openstack DHCP service - VMs can ping each other when they are in the same self-service network - VMs can ping to gateway in self-service network, which is virtual router made in openstack What I can't: - I can't get connectivity to external world - When my VM is directly attached to the provider network subnet I've made(172.16.0.0/24), it cannot ping gateway(172.16.0.1), which is the physical router connected to the physical switch(data switch) At router, there is no evidence of any packet coming from VMs (172.16.0.0/24 net) How can I fix this?...

$